The CHURCH stands at the extreme southeast end of the parish, on the site of the Roman station, where, it is supposed, there was at one time a considerable town. There appears to have been some doubt as to its dedication; Nicholson and Burn place it under the patronage of St. Cuthbert, and Hutchinson under St. Mary; but it is now invariably named after the northern saint. The present church is a plain structure, rebuilt in 1792-3, but a portion of the old chancel was incorporated in the present building. History is silent respecting its foundation, but we may reasonably ascribe to it a Saxon origin. The date 1066 occurs on an old buttress.
According to the testimony of Dr. Todd, the advowson was given, about the year 1200, to the prior and convent of Carlisle by Robert de Buetheastre, by whom is probably meant Robert de Vallibus.
The benefice is a rectory, valued in the King's Book (compiled from an ecclesiastical survey made in the reign of Henry VIII.) at £2. When Edward II. was taxing church livings in order to raise money to carry on his inglorious wars, he found Bewcastle in such a state of impecuniosity that there was not sufficient income to pay the stipend of the parish priest.
The living is now in the patronage of the Dean and Chapter of Carlisle, and is worth £200 a year. The tithes were commuted in 1842 for a yearly payment of £60 Os. 6d.; a rent charge of £20 a year was left by the late Sir James Graham; £26 a year is paid by the Ecclesiastical Commissioners; £31 Os. 1d. is the produce of money invested in the Furness railway; and £16 a year from Queen Anne's Bounty. The benefice is now held by the Rev. T. E. Laurie, M.A., who was inducted in 1874.